Dear Ms. Roy,
Or is it Mrs. Roy now? But then you never believed in the institution of marriage, did you?
How could you, with namesake lovers and spineless cowards, the nights of anguish and tremor, at times languishing in lackadaisical whimsies but never fulfilled. The knight never came, did he? Ha. And you stuck to telling stores of knights.
I can relate.
Where was I now?
See, this is exactly my problem with your second novel, the one I waited twenty years. The one that Amazon didn’t disappoint and I couldn’t imagine returning. The one for which I couldn’t wait for my babies to fall asleep, to be transported to your world. The one I read with just four hours of sleep some nights. The one I skipped dinner for and made up with a glass of wine and dark chocolate.
Oh, how you disappointed me your loyal fan, Ms. Roy!!!
You bring in Anjum brilliantly, I feel her and imagine my own story of her when I finally put the book down for some shut-eye. The next second, you bring in Tilo. Wait! What! Where is Anjum! Who is Hobart and why are we talking about Kashmir and what happened to the graves? The beautiful graves with not so beautiful people in them. Where is Begum? No, stop, wait, Sadam Hussain? Did Tilo love Naga or was it Musa? I know you marched with Maoist insurgents, I know you turned your attention from fiction to real world people movement. I admire you for all that and much more. But can we take a moment to drink in this novel. You mixed so many things into these pages, I lost everything in the end. There was no hang over.
I still gave you time to recover and redeem yourself. Maryam Ipe’s monologues helped, Dr.Azad Bhartiya did not.
Maybe it is I who have to be blamed. Perhaps I did not grow up with Estha and Rahel. They must be in their late forties now, yea?
The ministry that was supposed to provide my sleepless night with the utmost happiness had me looking like a ragged doll with hollow cheeks, sunken eyes, and blank outs.
Love,
Upsi
PS: Kazhu Ishiguro Nobel Prize vaangi, kettayirunno? Ningal ingane thanne irruno. Allandu pinne!