Modern robotic manipulation primarily relies on visual observations in a 2D color space for skill learning, but suffers from poor generalization. In contrast, humans, living in a 3D world, depend more on physical properties—such as distance, size, and shape—than on texture when interacting with objects. Since such 3D geometric information can be acquired from widely available depth cameras, it appears feasible to endow robots with similar perceptual capabilities. Our pilot study found that using depth cameras for manipulation is challenging, primarily due to their limited accuracy and susceptibility to various types of noise. In this work, we propose Camera Depth Models (CDMs) as a simple plugin on daily-use depth cameras, which take RGB images and raw depth signals as input and output denoised, accurate metric depth. To achieve this, we develop a neural data engine that generates high-quality paired data from simulation by modeling a depth camera's noise pattern. Our results show that CDMs achieve nearly simulation-level accuracy in depth prediction, effectively bridging the sim-to-real gap for manipulation tasks. Notably, our experiments demonstrate, for the first time, that a policy trained on raw simulated depth, without the need for adding noise, or real-world fine-tuning, generalizes seamlessly to real-world robots on two challenging long-horizon tasks involving articulated and slender objects, with little to no performance degradation. Further analysis reveals that sim-to-real success rates are strongly correlated with the quality of depth perception. We hope our findings will inspire future research in utilizing simulation data and 3D information in general robot policies.
ByteCameraDepth Dataset
We introduce ByteCameraDepth, a real-world multi-camera depth dataset comprising over 170,000 RGB-depth pairs from ten distinct configurations captured by seven depth cameras.
170K+
RGB-Depth Pairs
7
Depth Cameras
10
Configurations
Camera:
Scene:
Example Pairs:
RGB Image
Depth Image
Each Scene is Visualized in a Different Fixed Min-Max Range
** Note that our goal is NOT to identify if depth is a better visual modality than color , BUT to validate whether accurate geometry information contained in a more precise depth image can benefit manipulation. Therefore, the policies designed in our experiments are depth-only to exclude the effect of color information.
A Pilot Study on Imitation Learning with Only Depth
Depth Model
Toothpaste-and-Cup
Stack-Bowls
Pick Toothpaste
Put Toothpaste into Cup
Pick Bowl
Stack Bowls
None
0/15
0/15
6/15
3/15
CDM-D435
10/15
6/15
11/15
9/15
Results w/w.o CDM
50 demonstrations for each task, collected by teleoperation
Generalization Over Different Object Sizes
Policies trained without CDM cannot generalize to unseen sizes (0 SR), while CDM-enhanced policies show better generalization.
Demo Videos
Toothpaste-and-Cup Task
Stack-Bowls Task
Zero-Shot Sim-to-Real Transfer Results
Zero-shot sim-to-real results using CDMs as plugin in real-world robot pipeline.
* The policy is robust to external interruptions during the test.
Demo Videos
Kitchen Task - Real Robot
Canteen Task - Real Robot
Cam RGB/Depth (D435,30FPS)
CDM-D435 Depth (~6FPS)
Cam RGB/Depth (L515,30FPS)
CDM-L515 Depth (~6FPS)
Camera
Depth Model
Kitchen Task
Canteen Task
Pick Bowl
Put Bowl into Microwave
Close Microwave
Total
Pick Fork
Place Fork
Pick Plate
Dump Plate
Place Plate
Total
Sim (D435-View)
None
43/50
33/50
32/50
30/50
40/50
28/50
47/50
45/50
33/50
21/50
D435
None
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
PromptDA
11/30
5/30
0/30
0/30
17/30
16/30
7/30
2/30
6/30
1/30
PriorDA
16/30
8/30
7/30
7/30
30/30
30/30
1/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
CDM-D435
29/30
26/30
26/30
26/30
30/30
30/30
15/30
14/30
14/30
14/30
CDM-L515
29/30
22/30
16/30
14/30
30/30
29/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
Sim (L515-View)
None
43/50
34/50
37/50
32/50
40/50
26/50
46/50
43/50
31/50
20/50
L515
None
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
PromptDA
3/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
3/30
0/30
3/30
0/30
0/30
0/30
PriorDA
17/30
3/30
2/30
2/30
10/30
8/30
3/30
3/30
3/30
3/30
CDM-D435
22/30
11/30
9/30
9/30
13/30
11/30
11/30
10/30
9/30
9/30
CDM-L515
25/30
18/30
18/30
18/30
24/30
24/30
22/30
22/30
22/30
22/30
Sim-Real Comparisons
* Real-world videos are slightly speed up for alignment (~1.4x)
* denotes the model fine-tuning on the same synthesized data as CDMs.
Split
Depth Model
L1 ↓
RMSE ↓
AbsRel ↓
δ₀.₅ ↑
δ₁ ↑
D435 (IR Stereo)
CDM-D435 (Ours)
0.0258
0.0404
0.0312
0.9842
0.9951
CDM-L515 (Ours)
0.0182
0.0338
0.0217
0.9877
0.9956
PromptDA*(435)
0.0434
0.0666
0.0599
0.9459
0.9770
PromptDA*(515)
0.1830
0.2387
0.2750
0.8802
0.9186
PromptDA
0.0396
0.0691
0.0484
0.9503
0.9772
PriorDA
0.0388
0.0754
0.0461
0.9632
0.9880
Raw Depth
0.0550
0.1458
0.0708
0.9179
0.9543
L515 (D-ToF)
CDM-L515 (Ours)
0.0156
0.0297
0.0229
0.9754
0.9919
CDM-D435 (Ours)
0.0165
0.0349
0.0246
0.9613
0.9855
PromptDA*(515)
0.0235
0.0666
0.0349
0.9291
0.9730
PromptDA*(435)
0.0254
0.0438
0.0379
0.9234
0.9640
PromptDA
0.0207
0.0515
0.0304
0.9480
0.9699
PriorDA
0.0177
0.0385
0.0274
0.9502
0.9763
Raw Depth
0.0312
0.0813
0.0475
0.9098
0.9429
Depth Accuracy w.r.t Distance
To understand the working range of CDMs and help users effectively use them, we evaluated the depth accuracy of CDMs at various distances on the Hammer dataset. The results show that CDMs achieve high accuracy across different distances, with performance trends following the original camera capabilities while significantly reducing noise and errors.
Dataset Split:
D435 Split - Absolute Relative Error
D435 Split - L1 Error
L515 Split - Absolute Relative Error
L515 Split - L1 Error
Helios Split - Absolute Relative Error
Helios Split - L1 Error
Observations
Raw depth shows larger errors than manufacturer specifications (may be dataset bias)
CDMs maintain high accuracy within the camera's optimal working range
Performance trends follow the original camera capabilities while significantly reducing noise
Point Cloud Quality Comparison on ByteCameraDepth Dataset
Interactive 3D visualization of CDM processed point clouds from ByteCameraDepth dataset
Scene:
Camera:
ByteCameraDepth Camera View Parameters (Debug Mode)
Raw Depth Viewer
Position: (0, 0, 0)
Target: (0, 0, 0)
CDM Predicted Viewer
Position: (0, 0, 0)
Target: (0, 0, 0)
Scene: Living | Camera: D405
*Point clouds are downsampled from 640x480 to 90000 points.
Initializing viewer...
Raw Depth Point Cloud
Initializing viewer...
CDM-D405 Point Cloud
RGB Image
Camera Depth / CDM Depth
Method Overview
Neural Data Engine
We model depth camera noise patterns to generate high-quality paired data from simulation for training CDMs.
Camera Depth Models (CDMs)
CDMs process RGB images and noisy depth signals from specific depth cameras to produce high-quality, denoised metric depth.
Citation
@article{liu2025manipulation,
title={Manipulation as in Simulation: Enabling Accurate Geometry Perception in Robots},
author={Liu, Minghuan and Zhu, Zhengbang and Han, Xiaoshen and Hu, Peng and Lin, Haotong and
Li, Xinyao and Chen, Jingxiao and Xu, Jiafeng and Yang, Yichu and Lin, Yunfeng and
Li, Xinghang and Yu, Yong and Zhang, Weinan and Kong, Tao and Kang, Bingyi},
journal={arXiv preprint},
year={2025}
}