From blue-line brawls to full-blown melees, this season was a gritty masterclass in one of the sport of hockey’s greatest differentiators: dropping the gloves.
The 2024–25 NHL season didn’t just deliver highlight-reel goals and breakout rookies. It delivered pugilistic carnage. And for fans who remember the golden era of enforcers, the message was clear- the fight game is far from dead.

Fists, Fury and a Full 82
There were 297 regular-season fights and two more in the playoffs, marking a noticeable uptick from recent years. This wasn’t just nostalgia, or heat-of-the-moment scraps. These were meaningful fights with momentum swings, revenge arcs, and playoff implications.
The increase in intensity was felt league-wide, but especially among the usual suspects:
Nashville led the way with 37 tilts, followed closely by Boston and Utah at 30 each.
Compare that to the 2020–21 season, where pandemic-era protocols and a rising focus on speed and skill, saw fight totals dip below 200. Or rewind to 2007–08, when there were 664 total fights—more than double what we saw this year.
The shift is obvious: while fighting may no longer be the nightly norm, it’s become something more strategic, more deliberate, and arguably more impactful.

But let’s be clear: fewer fights doesn’t mean half-hearted donnys. When players did drop the gloves this past season, it was tied to storylines, history, or momentum swings that demanded a physical answer. It’s not fighting for the sake of fighting—it’s fighting to shift a game’s narrative.
Rookie Brawlers Make Their Mark
Matt Rempe vs. Dylan McIlrath
On October 29, Rangers forward Matt Rempe returned from the AHL and wasted no time reasserting himself. Facing off against Washington’s Dylan McIlrath, Rempe reignited an old rivalry from their AHL days.
The bout lasted nearly three minutes, with both players dishing out bombs in a gritty center-ice slugfest. Rempe was eventually taken down, but not before proving he could handle himself against one of the NHL’s most seasoned enforcers. He finished the season with 67 penalty minutes in just 42 games.
Rempe vs. Arber Xhekaj
January 19, Bell Centre. Montreal’s Arber Xhekaj met Rempe in a heavyweight clash that shook the rafters. The Rempe vs. Xhekaj scrap featured early punches from Rempe, followed by a relentless barrage from Xhekaj that brought the crowd to its feet.
Xhekaj’s technical edge and takedown sealed the moment as one of the best heavyweight battles of the season.
Veteran Brawlers Reassert Their Presence
Josh Anderson vs. Jacob Trouba
Canadiens forward Josh Anderson took issue with a hit from Rangers captain Jacob Trouba. The result? A punishing sequence that saw Anderson deliver a beatdown in front of a stunned Madison Square Garden. The bout earned a 7.85 fan rating.
Josh Anderson vs. Tom Wilson
One day later, Anderson followed up by dismantling Capitals bruiser Tom Wilson on Halloween night. The Canadiens winger walked away with a dominant 94% fan vote win.
These back-to-back showcases by Anderson signaled to the league: Montreal wasn’t backing down from anyone.
Heavyweight Classics That Shook the League
Olivier vs. Reaves
On January 22, fans were gifted the ultimate enforcer battle: Mathieu Olivier vs. Ryan Reaves. The fight saw Olivier gain an early advantage, knocking Reaves off balance before the Maple Leafs veteran rallied with counter-punches. The 7.83 rating said it all—this was a masterclass in big-man brawling.
Olivier vs. Xhekaj
November 16 featured another Olivier bout, this time with Xhekaj at the Bell Centre. Olivier won the fan vote, but Xhekaj’s grit and control marked him as a top-tier enforcer.
Rivalries and Retaliation
This season wasn’t just about one-off fights—it was about bad blood boiling over.
Flames vs. Oilers
The Battle of Alberta didn’t disappoint. On multiple occasions, line brawls and aggressive checking sparked skirmishes, with Brett Ritchie and Evander Kane squaring off in what fans called the most heated moment of the rivalry.
Bruins vs. Leafs
Toronto’s Ryan Reaves tangled with Bruins enforcer Trent Frederic on two separate occasions, both earning over 6.0 fight ratings. The Atlantic Division rivalry gained an edge that felt like vintage playoff hockey.
Panthers vs. Lightning
Florida and Tampa Bay continued their playoff-fueled feud with multiple dustups during regular-season matchups, culminating in a fight between Radko Gudas and Tanner Jeannot that drew comparisons to their 2022–23 playoff clashes.
Top Enforcers of the Season
Mathieu Olivier
- Team: Columbus Blue Jackets
- Fights: 10
- PIM: 97
- Signature Win: vs. Reaves
Arber Xhekaj
- Team: Montreal Canadiens
- Fights: 6
- PIM: 81
- Notable: Dominated multiple heavyweights
Josh Anderson
- Team: Montreal Canadiens
- Fights: 5
- Notable Victories: Trouba, Wilson
Matt Rempe
- Team: New York Rangers
- Fights: 7
- Penalty Minutes: 67
Ryan Reaves
- Team: Toronto Maple Leafs
- Fights: 6
- Notable Bout: vs. Olivier
The State of Fighting in the NHL
Fighting in the NHL continues to evolve.
Rule changes have adjusted the dynamics—players who drop the gloves with helmets off face extra penalties, and referees are quicker to break up staged fights. Yet that hasn’t stopped fighters from stepping up when needed.
There’s also been cultural change. Enforcers now often double as useful bottom-six forwards. Many top fighters—like Duhaime and Xhekaj—aren’t just muscle; they’re versatile role players who can kill penalties or pressure the puck.
Analytics may dominate roster construction today, but there’s still room in the game for the guys who make sure your stars don’t get pushed around.
Fan Culture & Reactions
This season saw a massive wave of fan support for hockey fights. Social media lit up after the Rempe–Xhekaj bout. Memes, slow-mo edits, and breakdowns flooded TikTok and Instagram.
YouTube channels like Steve Dangle and Spittin’ Chiclets gave extra attention to the art of fighting, breaking down positioning and momentum.
Crowd reactions were just as wild. Bell Centre, Scotiabank Arena, and Bridgestone Arena fans regularly erupted for fights. One viral clip captured fans throwing hats for a fight win, not a hat trick.
Playoff Pandemonium
Panthers vs. Oilers – Game 3
Game 3 of the Stanley Cup Final was pure mayhem. Five separate fights broke out. The biggest came from Nurse vs. Gadjovich, a back-and-forth war fans are still talking about.
Game footage showed everything—from Sam Bennett breaking Trent Frederic’s stick with a cross-check to a 9-year-old fan’s now-famous quote: “I really liked how they punched each other. A lot.”
Looking Ahead: 2025–26
If the 2024–25 season taught us anything, it’s that fighting is far from dead—it’s just smarter, sharper, and more contextual than ever.
Young blood is rising. Leonard, Rempe, Duhaime—they’re setting the tone for a new class of enforcers. Teams have learned that grit still wins in April and May, and management is responding accordingly.
Will we see 300+ fights again next season? Maybe. But it’s not the volume that matters—it’s the purpose, the meaning, and the electricity each one delivers. And in that sense, the tradition is alive and well.















