Bonus: we can present the analytics data using the inspector itself. I'm almost crying as I'm writing this. It is a thing of beauty; Father McCarthy smiles upon us from heaven.

❤️

The proposal looks pretty good to me. I'm just wondering about one thing - would it be nice to have some mechanism to add/remove some of the analytics as a client. Adding, because I assume some people would have specific needs, and removing - in case someone runs into issues (e.g. performance) with some of them.

But overall I love the feature and the implementation looks pretty good to me.

The proposal looks pretty good to me. I'm just wondering about one thing - would it be nice to have some mechanism to add/remove some of the analytics as a client. Adding, because I assume some people would have specific needs, and removing - in case someone runs into issues (e.g. performance) with some of them.

I've thought about this overall, and this is how I see it:

• The current calculations are cheap, you can count on me measuring and optimizing that. The whole thing comes back in ~1ms for 100k non-trivial items.
• When deciding what to calculate, the price is one of my primary criteria. For example, I haven't put in median/percentiles calculations yet, as it would be more expensive. Probably still affordable, but they didn't make it into the first batch.
• If people ever want to add something else, I'd say they'll have to do it by contributing to Orchard directly where we can vet. It's too early to make this thing extendable.
• Given all that, I don't think it will have value to disable some of the calculations at least for now. The configuration fatigue is a real thing, and I'd like to keep this config-free as long as it's possible.

No argument from me. Just to be clear - I wasn't thinking of configuration options, but rather some mechanism where users could contribute extra analytics just by defining simple functions in their own codebase. But that was just a general remark and not something I'm pushing to do right now. Premature optimization in the root of all evil. :-)

I agree. I think there can be space for user-extendable analytics in the future.