| CARVIEW |
Select Language
HTTP/2 301
server: nginx
date: Wed, 21 Jan 2026 05:44:56 GMT
content-type: text/html; charset=UTF-8
location: https://evolutionspace.wordpress.com/category/game/
x-hacker: Want root? Visit join.a8c.com/hacker and mention this header.
host-header: WordPress.com
link: ; rel="https://api.w.org/"
vary: accept, content-type, cookie
x-redirect-by: WordPress
x-ac: 2.bom _dca MISS
alt-svc: h3=":443"; ma=86400
strict-transport-security: max-age=31536000
server-timing: a8c-cdn, dc;desc=bom, cache;desc=MISS;dur=328.0
HTTP/2 200
server: nginx
date: Wed, 21 Jan 2026 05:44:57 GMT
content-type: text/html; charset=UTF-8
vary: Accept-Encoding
x-hacker: Want root? Visit join.a8c.com/hacker and mention this header.
host-header: WordPress.com
link: ; rel="https://api.w.org/"
vary: accept, content-type, cookie
content-encoding: gzip
x-ac: 4.bom _dca MISS
alt-svc: h3=":443"; ma=86400
strict-transport-security: max-age=31536000
server-timing: a8c-cdn, dc;desc=bom, cache;desc=MISS;dur=396.0
game | Evolution Space
jump to navigation
add a comment
Evolution Space
news and blabbering on evolution, atheism and religious-fundamentalism
Spot the Errors Wednesday, May 16, 2007
Posted by Henry in anti-evolution, anti-fundamentalism, book review, Darwin, David Sloan Wilson, evolution, fundamentalism, game, logic, rationality, science, straw-man.add a comment
Let’s play a game.
Here is a paragraph taken from a book review article (more on this later):
We can put this point in a syllogistic form for the sake of convenience and handy usage. If evolution is true about everything, then we are doomed to live in a world without truth, beauty, and goodness. If we are not doomed, then evolution is not true about everything. And if evolution is not true about everything, then there is good reason to think that it is not true about anything.
How many errors, confusions and/or logical fallacies can you find in this single paragraph?
In the spirit of not quoting it out of context, here is the background. The article is written by a professor named Stephen Webb as a book review. The book is “Evolution for Everyone“, written by David Sloan Wilson.
The “point” mentioned in the paragraph refers to one of the main theme of the book, that Darwinian thinking can be applied to “all things human”, such as the way languages and cultures change and adapt over time, how we perceive beauty, and so on.
So the first error, I would say, is the straw-man argument that the book claims evolutionary truth in everything. That is not the point of the book, and the rest of the paragraph can be ignored.
-
Admin Controls
Features
-
Top Posts
- Blog Break...
- Australian Pastor Had Sex With His Daughters - To Teach Them To Be Good Wives
- This Is Disturbing - Comic
- Chill Out, Faith Heads
- The Peppered Moths Stike Back
- Teach Alternatives in Chemistry - Comic
- Some Thoughts on Dawkin's Enemies of Reason (Part I)
- Scientists, NCSE Wants You
- Darwinism and Its Discontents - Book Review
- Truly Sad - WordPress Censored in Turkey - Creationist Harun Yahya Involved
-
Recent Posts
Favourite Posts
- World Wide Atheism Trend and Pattern - A Summary
- Not Only In America - Evolution in Science Endangered Worldwide
- The Monthly Dembski Watch - July 2007
- Human Protein Evolution Traced - at Atomic Level...!
- Echoing Dawkins - Don't Call Us Fundamentalists
- Full Transcript of Brian Lehrer Interviewing Richard Dawkins
- How To Think Like a Religious Fundamentalist
- Do Evolutionists Believe in God? A Study
Blogroll
- A Whore in the Temple of Reason
- Aetiology
- Afarensis
- All-Too-Common-Dissent
- Atheist Comics
- Atheist Perspective
- Atheist Revolution
- Bay Of Fundie
- Blue Rat
- blueollie
- Creationism v Evolution
- Darwin’s Dagger
- Darwiniana
- de-Conversion
- ERV
- Evolgen
- EvolutionBlog
- Evolved Rational
- Evolving Thoughts
- Friendly Atheist
- Fundie Watch
- Genomicron
- Good Math, Bad Math
- In The Name Of Towelie
- John Hawks Anthropology Weblog
- Laelaps
- Machines Like Us
- Matt’s Notepad
- NeuroLogica Blog
- nullifidian
- Pharyngula
- Playing Chess with Pigeons
- Point of Equiry
- Rant & Reason
- Rationally Speaking
- Religion and Atheism
- Religion, Atheism, Politics and Science
- Respectiful Insolence
- Sandwalk
- Sapiens Anonym
- Scientia Natura
- Spanish Inquisitor
- Stranger Fruit
- The Evilutionary Biologist
- The Fake God Blog
- The Friends of Charles Darwin
- The Panda’s Thumb
- The Questionable Authority
- The Secular Web
- The View from the Pond
- The Wisdom of Repugnance
- This Week in Evolution
- Tiny Frog
- Topix Evolution News
- Truth In Science: Revealed – Exposing Creationists in the UK
- Uncommon Descent
- WASP
websites
Categories
- Adnan Oktar
- Afghanistan
- Africa
- agnosticism
- Allah
- animation
- anthropology
- anti-creationism
- anti-evolution
- anti-fundamentalism
- anti-ID
- art
- artificial intelligence
- artwork
- Asian Tsunami 2004
- atheism
- Atlas of Creation
- Australia
- Australia Aborigines
- Australopithecus
- bacteria
- Baptist
- BBC
- Behe
- Bible
- biochemistry
- biology
- bloggers
- Blogs
- blooper
- book review
- Brian Lehrer
- Buddha
- Buddhism
- Butler University
- Canada
- car paint job
- Catholics
- censorship
- charity
- Charles Darwin
- chemical catalyst
- chemistry
- China
- Chinese
- Christianity
- Christopher Hitchens
- Chu-Carroll
- church
- Church of England
- comic
- consilience
- Cornell Evolution Project
- creation museum
- creationism
- crime
- Daniel Dennett
- Darwin
- Darwinism
- DaveScot
- David Eller
- David Sloan Wilson
- Dawkins
- Dembski
- Dennett
- Dinesh D'Souza
- dinosaur
- Discovery Institute
- discrimination
- DNA
- Dollo's Law
- Ed Current
- Edip Yuksel
- education
- electronica
- Eller
- embryology
- enzyme
- Eugenie Scott
- Europe
- European Union
- Evangelical
- evolution
- exobiology
- Explore Evolution
- faith
- family
- flood
- football
- Fox News
- Fred Hoyle
- fundamentalism
- funny
- game
- gay marriage
- gene flow
- general
- genetic engineering
- genetics
- genome
- geology
- George Bush
- God
- Gould
- graffiti
- Haeckel
- Harold Urey
- Harun Yahya
- hate-crime
- hell
- Hinduism
- hoax
- homo erectus
- homo sapien
- homosexuality
- honor killing
- horizontal gene transfer
- human evolution
- humanism
- humanist
- humanitarian
- humor
- humour
- Inca Trail
- incest
- intelligent design
- Iraq
- Islam
- Italy
- Japan
- Jason Rosenhouse
- Jeffrey Ventrella
- Jehovah's Witnesses
- Jerry Coyne
- Jerry Falwell
- Jesus
- jihad
- Judaism
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Koran
- Korea
- Kurdish
- Larry Moran
- Lewis Wolpert
- logic
- love
- Machu Pichu
- Malaysia
- map
- mathematics
- Melanesian
- Michael Behe
- Michael Egnor
- Michael Shermer
- Michael Zimmerman
- microbiology
- Middle East
- Miller-Urey
- moral issues
- morality
- morphology
- murders
- museums
- Natural Atheism
- natural selection
- naturalism
- NCSE
- New Guinea
- nightmare
- Noam Chomsky
- North Korea
- Notable Quotes Series
- numerology
- organisms
- origin of life
- OUT campaign
- paleontology
- parody
- Peru
- Pete Stark
- philosophy
- photos
- photoshop
- physics
- pics
- Piltdown Man
- plasma
- podcast
- political correctness
- politics
- polls
- pope
- Portugal
- prayer
- protein
- psychiatry
- punctuated equilibrium
- PZ Myers
- quiz
- quotes
- radio interview
- radio talk show
- rationality
- reason
- religion
- Richard Dawkins
- Rick Warren
- Sam Brownback
- Sam Harris
- sarcasm
- Scandinavian
- science
- science experiment
- Science Weekly
- scientific model
- scientific theory
- scientists
- scientology
- scriptures
- sea snails
- secularism
- Seoul
- sex
- Sikhism
- Simon conway Morris
- simulation
- sin
- soccer
- software
- South Australia
- South Korea
- spirituality
- Stanley Miller
- statistics
- stem cell
- Stephen Gould
- Steven Novella
- straw-man
- superstition
- survey
- Sweden
- T. Ryan Gregory
- Tara Smith
- Ten Commandments
- Texas
- The Clergy Letter Project
- theism
- Time Magazine
- top 100
- Toronto
- tragedy
- transcript
- Truth In Science
- Turkey
- UK
- Uncommon Descent
- United Kingdom
- United States
- Vatican
- video
- Vietnam
- violence
- Virginia Tech Massacre
- weight loss
- Why Darwin Matters
- William Dembski
- WNYC
- WordPress
- world
- Zambia
Links
-
Archives
-
Subscribe
Subscribed
Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
Evolution Space