Amtrak has urged the U.S. Surface Transportation Board to reject a bid by Canadian National to obtain a route to Kansas City as part of the proposed merger of Canadian Pacific and Kansas City Southern.
CN is seeking a former Gulf, Mobile & Ohio route now owned by KCS between Kansas City and Springfield, Illinois, and operating as the Gateway Western.
Amtrak fears that if CN gets the route and carries through on its plans to expand freight service between to Kansas City this would impair operations of Amtrak passenger trains on other CN routes.
Affected in particular, Amtrak said, would be trains using CN track between Chicago and New Orleans via Carbondale, Illinois.
The congestion on that former Illinois Central line would be most acute between Chicago and Gilman, Illinois. At Gilman, trains would diverge from the Chicago-New Orleans route to an ex-IC route to Springfield that at one time continued to St. Louis.
CN trains could potentially cause delays to Amtrak’s Chicago-St. Louis Lincoln Service trains as well as the Chicago-San Antonio Texas Eagle.
As it is, Amtrak and CN have been locked in dispute for years over CN’s dispatching of the Chicago-Carbondale route with Amtrak claiming CN needlessly delays passenger trains on that route.
CN has asked the STB to require KCS to sell the Springfield-Kansas City route as a requirement of approval of the CP-KCS merger. CN has said it would use the “Springfield Speedway” to provide freight service to Kansas City from Chicago, Detroit, St. Louis and eastern Canada.
CP and KCS have rejected the request and urged the STB to deny it.
In its filing with the STB, Amtrak described as woeful the on-time performance of its trains operating between Chicago and Gilman.
Also affected would be Amtrak service using a joint Union Pacific-KCS line in Illinois between East St. Louis and Godfrey.
Amtrak said other segments of the CN system that it uses could see longer or additional CN trains including track in Memphis used by the City of New Orleans, and three CN lines in Michigan used by corridor trains operating between Chicago and Detroit (Pontiac) and Port Huron.
The Amtrak filing with the STB said that CN in 2015 told federal regulators that lack of capacity in the Chicago-Carbondale corridor was the major issue causing Amtrak trains there to be late.
But now, Amtrak said in its filing, CN claims to have excess capacity on the Chicago-Carbondale route between Chicago and Gilman.
The filing said CN operate at least 20 freight trains a day on its track between Chicago and Carbondale.
CN contends in its own filings with regulators that the Chicago-Gilman segment could handle two additional CN trains a day without interfering with Amtrak trains.
Amtrak contends that the St. Louis-Godfrey segment, which is dispatched by UP, routinely sees passenger trains encounter freight train interference that would be exacerbated by the addition of CN trains to the route.
The Amtrak filing said CN has assured it that any trains it runs on the St. Louis-Godfrey segment won’t adversely affect Amtrak, but the Montreal-based Class 1 carrier has not conducted a capacity analysis to support that assertion.
For more information, visit https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/amtrak-urges-regulators-to-reject-cns-request-to-gain-control-of-kcss-former-gateway-western-trackage/