CARVIEW |
Select Language
HTTP/2 200
date: Wed, 23 Jul 2025 07:39:37 GMT
content-type: text/html; charset=UTF-8
cache-control: s-maxage=36000, max-age=5
last-modified: Tue, 22 Jul 2025 13:57:50 GMT
link: ; rel=preload; as=style,; rel=preload; as=style,; rel=preload; as=style,; rel=preload; as=style,; rel=preload; as=style,; rel=preload; as=style
strict-transport-security: max-age=31536000
content-security-policy: upgrade-insecure-requests
edge-cache-tag: CT-131533745792,CG-3298168043,P-691534,CW-187104649349,CW-187104649527,CW-187105507506,CW-189729484136,CW-190415809340,CW-191913064573,CW-191913064712,CW-191913080068,CW-191913080408,CW-191913080670,CW-191914485575,CW-191914485848,E-142751494144,E-142762480291,E-142762558863,E-143617032215,E-168591795996,E-182000650417,E-182007043681,E-182007308374,E-187267399945,E-187268190600,E-191724244992,E-191748641714,E-191757015191,E-191757745199,E-191757745212,E-191757922448,E-191757922456,E-191757922459,E-191795252125,E-191913064739,E-191913064788,E-191913064825,E-191913065836,E-191914486142,E-191914486457,E-191914488151,E-191914503720,E-191916206874,E-191916207449,E-191916207620,E-191917277727,E-191917277783,E-191917277866,E-191917560667,E-191917560701,MENU-154931019020,MENU-168587867317,PGS-ALL,SW-3,GC-143174116914,GC-165023483770,GC-187118171939,TS-142763766447
permissions-policy: true
referrer-policy: no-referrer-when-downgrade
x-content-type-options: nosniff
x-frame-options: SAMEORIGIN
x-hs-cache-config: BrowserCache-5s-EdgeCache-180s
x-hs-cache-control: s-maxage=36000, max-age=0
x-hs-cf-cache-status: EXPIRED
x-hs-cfworker-meta: {"contentType":"BLOG_POST"}
x-hs-content-id: 131533745792
x-hs-hub-id: 691534
x-hs-prerendered: Tue, 22 Jul 2025 13:57:50 GMT
set-cookie: __cf_bm=hTxUKkrax.gh5yzOYXWEx6lANAefb4heXRpkAPkZFPg-1753256377-1.0.1.1-Zb_XWp5ViwabYOGDhKeHCmFd4F7Jnz5s2k28aGf0Ew38VDc4W147Cc.TNdhtr4MfRypr5O.Zg6pw0IxiWxXbE2NpaCB04IIJ9_sOXEQti4o; path=/; expires=Wed, 23-Jul-25 08:09:37 GMT; domain=.www.pythian.com; HttpOnly; Secure; SameSite=None
report-to: {"endpoints":[{"url":"https:\/\/a.nel.cloudflare.com\/report\/v4?s=67aaTpe0xfpDkfyve8fj11OdvyDRIagKq328BrGLDZ4GJnHdDjmqcIJmvT6SCBlrJwSGd6Fyc75C5TFI%2BeR%2BbozAXkQs1v3gDq4zOYVSsqq2%2FsWRYNaPq1QQgW0o6OTuiA%3D%3D"}],"group":"cf-nel","max_age":604800}
nel: {"success_fraction":0.01,"report_to":"cf-nel","max_age":604800}
vary: Accept-Encoding
set-cookie: _cfuvid=TQSCA3AYyY_K8ou9L0jj1kw_la3d3z4WBXKinOEATZ0-1753256377627-0.0.1.1-604800000; path=/; domain=.www.pythian.com; HttpOnly; Secure; SameSite=None
server: cloudflare
cf-ray: 9639866019e8d3d4-BLR
content-encoding: gzip
alt-svc: h3=":443"; ma=86400
Examining the Lifecycle of Tombstones in Apache Cassandra
This post is the first part of a series of blog posts regarding the lifecycle and management of tombstones.
Deleting and expiring data in Cassandra is something that you should carefully plan. Especially if you’re about to delete a massive amount of data at once. Without proper planning, this can bring problems to the cluster like an increase in read-latency and disk usage footprint. Throughout this post, I will describe a way of tackling this and its caveats.
First, let's go over the basics. In Cassandra, the data files (SSTables) existing on disk are immutable files. When we are deleting something in Cassandra, a new SSTable is created that contains a marker. This marker indicates which partition, row, or cell was removed along with the timestamp for that deletion. This deletion marker is called a tombstone.
The deleted data and the tombstone can coexist on the disk during a period called gc_grace_seconds, which is by default 10 days. During this time, although the data can still exist on the drive, it's not returned to the client if queried. Which means that from a client point of perspective, the data is deleted as soon as you execute the delete statement. However, from an operational point of view, both the data and the tombstone can still exist and occupy space on the disk. This deleted data which still exists on disk is called “shadowed data.”
N.B.: In the previous paragraph I say that the data and the tombstones "can still coexist on disc" (emphasis on the "can") because if compaction occurs that involves the data and the tombstones, then the data is evicted. But the tombstone will remain if gc_grace_seconds has not passed.
The gc_grace_seconds is a safety mechanism to ensure that the tombstone has enough time to replicate to all nodes that have a replica of the shadowed data. For this safety mechanism to be successful, you must be able to repair the cluster every gc_grace_seconds. Meaning that if you are using the default 10 days for gc_grace_seconds, a repair must be started and finished within every 10 days. The repair serves the purpose of preventing zombie data in the cluster. I won't go into the details of how this can happen, but basically, zombie data occurs when you delete data, but it returns sometime later.
After gc_grace_seconds has passed, the data and the tombstone can finally be evicted from the disk, recovering the disk space previously used by them (Figure 1). The ETA to release the disk space is one of the first points that I want to clarify in this post. When using Cassandra, many people find this mechanism surprising, i.e., that after deleting data, the data still exists on disk. This confusion is usually quickly clarified as soon as people learn about tombstones and gc_grace_seconds. However, it seems that operators tend to think that the data and the tombstones are evicted right after gc_grace_seconds has finished. In fact, it's essential to be aware that this might not (and tends not) to be true. Usually, it takes longer than gc_grace_seconds for this eviction to happen and the disk space recovered. [caption id="attachment_106618" align="aligncenter" width="852"]
Figure 1 - compacting shadowed data with expired and non-expired tombstones[/caption]
The eviction mentioned above happens when compaction occurs that involves the SSTables that have the shadowed data and the tombstone. Only then, the data is effectively removed, and the disk space recovered. It's important to note that even if gc_grace_seconds has passed and the SSTable with the shadowed data is compacted with another SSTable that does not have the tombstone, then the shadowed data is not purged. The same thing happens for the tombstone markers, i.e., if the SSTable with the tombstone is not compacted with all the SSTables that still have data that was deleted, then the tombstone is not evicted from the disk. The reason this happens is that during compaction, Cassandra does not know what's in the SSTables that are not involved in the compaction. So it has no way to know that it can discard the data since it can't see the tombstone. You can see this in Figure 2 where, although gc_grace_seconds has passed for both tombstones, nothing is evicted after the compaction. [caption id="attachment_106620" align="aligncenter" width="851"]
Figure 2 - compacting shadowed data and their tombstones separately[/caption]
Due to the disk usage by the data and the tombstone marker, the accumulation of tombstones can impact read-latency, because Cassandra needs to read lots of tombstones before returning live data.
Deleting data is usually not a problem if these deletions are small and sparse. Because, over the natural compaction lifecycle, Cassandra eventually recovers the disk space and the purged tombstones. However, if you're deleting a large amount of data at once, that creates many tombstones and can quickly impact your read-latency.
If you need to delete a large amount of data on an ad-hoc basis, then there are some steps in the next blog post that you can take to mitigate risks.
Share this
Examining the Lifecycle of Tombstones in Apache Cassandra
by Pedro Gordo on Jun 19, 2019 12:00:00 AM


Share this
- Technical Track (967)
- Oracle (413)
- MySQL (141)
- Cloud (128)
- Microsoft SQL Server (117)
- Open Source (90)
- Google Cloud (81)
- Microsoft Azure (63)
- Amazon Web Services (AWS) (58)
- Big Data (52)
- Google Cloud Platform (46)
- Cassandra (44)
- DevOps (41)
- Pythian (33)
- Linux (30)
- Database (26)
- Performance (25)
- Podcasts (25)
- Site Reliability Engineering (25)
- PostgreSQL (24)
- Oracle E-Business Suite (23)
- Oracle Database (22)
- Docker (21)
- DBA (20)
- Security (20)
- Exadata (18)
- MongoDB (18)
- Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI) (18)
- Oracle Exadata (18)
- Automation (17)
- Hadoop (16)
- Oracleebs (16)
- Amazon RDS (15)
- Ansible (15)
- Snowflake (15)
- ASM (13)
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) (13)
- BigQuery (13)
- Replication (13)
- Advanced Analytics (12)
- Data (12)
- GenAI (12)
- Kubernetes (12)
- LLM (12)
- Authentication, SSO and MFA (11)
- Cloud Migration (11)
- Machine Learning (11)
- Rman (11)
- Datascape Podcast (10)
- Monitoring (10)
- Oracle Applications (10)
- Apache Cassandra (9)
- ChatGPT (9)
- Data Guard (9)
- Infrastructure (9)
- Python (9)
- Series (9)
- AWR (8)
- High Availability (8)
- Oracle EBS (8)
- Oracle Enterprise Manager (OEM) (8)
- Percona (8)
- Apache Beam (7)
- Data Governance (7)
- Innodb (7)
- Microsoft Azure SQL Database (7)
- Migration (7)
- Myrocks (7)
- Performance Tuning (7)
- Data Enablement (6)
- Data Visualization (6)
- Database Performance (6)
- Oracle Enterprise Manager (6)
- Orchestrator (6)
- RocksDB (6)
- Serverless (6)
- Azure Data Factory (5)
- Azure Synapse Analytics (5)
- Covid-19 (5)
- Disaster Recovery (5)
- Generative AI (5)
- Google BigQuery (5)
- Mariadb (5)
- Microsoft (5)
- Scala (5)
- Windows (5)
- Xtrabackup (5)
- Airflow (4)
- Analytics (4)
- Apex (4)
- Cloud Security (4)
- Cloud Spanner (4)
- CockroachDB (4)
- Data Management (4)
- Data Pipeline (4)
- Data Security (4)
- Data Strategy (4)
- Database Administrator (4)
- Database Management (4)
- Database Migration (4)
- Dataflow (4)
- Fusion Middleware (4)
- Google (4)
- Oracle Autonomous Database (Adb) (4)
- Oracle Cloud (4)
- Prometheus (4)
- Redhat (4)
- Slob (4)
- Ssl (4)
- Terraform (4)
- Amazon Relational Database Service (Rds) (3)
- Apache Kafka (3)
- Apexexport (3)
- Aurora (3)
- Business Intelligence (3)
- Cloud Armor (3)
- Cloud Database (3)
- Cloud FinOps (3)
- Cosmos Db (3)
- Data Analytics (3)
- Data Integration (3)
- Database Monitoring (3)
- Database Troubleshooting (3)
- Database Upgrade (3)
- Databases (3)
- Dataops (3)
- Digital Transformation (3)
- ERP (3)
- Google Chrome (3)
- Google Cloud Sql (3)
- Google Workspace (3)
- Graphite (3)
- Heterogeneous Database Migration (3)
- Liquibase (3)
- Oracle Data Guard (3)
- Oracle Live Sql (3)
- Oracle Rac (3)
- Perl (3)
- Rdbms (3)
- Remote Teams (3)
- S3 (3)
- SAP (3)
- Tensorflow (3)
- Adf (2)
- Adop (2)
- Amazon Data Migration Service (2)
- Amazon Ec2 (2)
- Amazon S3 (2)
- Apache Flink (2)
- Ashdump (2)
- Atp (2)
- Autonomous (2)
- Awr Data Mining (2)
- Cloud Cost Optimization (2)
- Cloud Data Fusion (2)
- Cloud Hosting (2)
- Cloud Infrastructure (2)
- Cloud Shell (2)
- Cloud Sql (2)
- Conferences (2)
- Cosmosdb (2)
- Cost Management (2)
- Cyber Security (2)
- Data Analysis (2)
- Data Discovery (2)
- Data Engineering (2)
- Data Migration (2)
- Data Modeling (2)
- Data Quality (2)
- Data Streaming (2)
- Data Warehouse (2)
- Database Consulting (2)
- Database Migrations (2)
- Dataguard (2)
- Docker-Composer (2)
- Enterprise Data Platform (EDP) (2)
- Etl (2)
- Events (2)
- Gemini (2)
- Health Check (2)
- Infrastructure As Code (2)
- Innodb Cluster (2)
- Innodb File Structure (2)
- Innodb Group Replication (2)
- NLP (2)
- Neo4J (2)
- Nosql (2)
- Open Source Database (2)
- Oracle Datase (2)
- Oracle Extended Manager (Oem) (2)
- Oracle Flashback (2)
- Oracle Forms (2)
- Oracle Installation (2)
- Oracle Io Testing (2)
- Podcast (2)
- Power Bi (2)
- Redshift (2)
- Remote DBA (2)
- Remote Sre (2)
- SAP HANA Cloud (2)
- Single Sign-On (2)
- Webinars (2)
- X5 (2)
- Actifio (1)
- Adf Custom Email (1)
- Adrci (1)
- Advanced Data Services (1)
- Afd (1)
- Ahf (1)
- Alloydb (1)
- Amazon (1)
- Amazon Athena (1)
- Amazon Aurora Backtrack (1)
- Amazon Efs (1)
- Amazon Redshift (1)
- Amazon Sagemaker (1)
- Amazon Vpc Flow Logs (1)
- Analysis (1)
- Analytical Models (1)
- Anisble (1)
- Anthos (1)
- Apache (1)
- Apache Nifi (1)
- Apache Spark (1)
- Application Migration (1)
- Ash (1)
- Asmlib (1)
- Atlas CLI (1)
- Awr Mining (1)
- Aws Lake Formation (1)
- Azure Data Lake (1)
- Azure Data Lake Analytics (1)
- Azure Data Lake Store (1)
- Azure Data Migration Service (1)
- Azure OpenAI (1)
- Azure Sql Data Warehouse (1)
- Batches In Cassandra (1)
- Business Insights (1)
- Chown (1)
- Chrome Security (1)
- Cloud Browser (1)
- Cloud Build (1)
- Cloud Consulting (1)
- Cloud Data Warehouse (1)
- Cloud Database Management (1)
- Cloud Dataproc (1)
- Cloud Foundry (1)
- Cloud Manager (1)
- Cloud Networking (1)
- Cloud SQL Replica (1)
- Cloud Scheduler (1)
- Cloud Services (1)
- Cloud Strategies (1)
- Compliance (1)
- Conversational AI (1)
- DAX (1)
- Data Analytics Platform (1)
- Data Box (1)
- Data Classification (1)
- Data Cleansing (1)
- Data Encryption (1)
- Data Estate (1)
- Data Flow Management (1)
- Data Insights (1)
- Data Integrity (1)
- Data Lake (1)
- Data Leader (1)
- Data Lifecycle Management (1)
- Data Lineage (1)
- Data Masking (1)
- Data Mesh (1)
- Data Migration Assistant (1)
- Data Migration Service (1)
- Data Mining (1)
- Data Monetization (1)
- Data Policy (1)
- Data Profiling (1)
- Data Protection (1)
- Data Retention (1)
- Data Safe (1)
- Data Sheets (1)
- Data Summit (1)
- Data Vault (1)
- Data Warehouse Modernization (1)
- Database Auditing (1)
- Database Consultant (1)
- Database Link (1)
- Database Modernization (1)
- Database Provisioning (1)
- Database Provisioning Failed (1)
- Database Replication (1)
- Database Scaling (1)
- Database Schemas (1)
- Database Security (1)
- Databricks (1)
- Datascape 59 (1)
- DeepSeek (1)
- Duet AI (1)
- Edp (1)
- Gcp Compute (1)
- Gcp-Spanner (1)
- Global Analytics (1)
- Google Analytics (1)
- Google Cloud Architecture Framework (1)
- Google Cloud Data Services (1)
- Google Cloud Partner (1)
- Google Cloud Spanner (1)
- Google Cloud VMware Engine (1)
- Google Compute Engine (1)
- Google Dataflow (1)
- Google Datalab (1)
- Google Grab And Go (1)
- Graph Algorithms (1)
- Graph Databases (1)
- Graph Inferences (1)
- Graph Theory (1)
- GraphQL (1)
- Healthcheck (1)
- Information (1)
- Infrastructure As A Code (1)
- Innobackupex (1)
- Innodb Concurrency (1)
- Innodb Flush Method (1)
- It Industry (1)
- Kubeflow (1)
- LMSYS Chatbot Arena (1)
- Linux Host Monitoring (1)
- Linux Storage Appliance (1)
- Looker (1)
- MMLU (1)
- Managed Services (1)
- Migrate (1)
- Migrating Ssis Catalog (1)
- Migration Checklist (1)
- MongoDB Atlas (1)
- MongoDB Compass (1)
- Newsroom (1)
- Nifi (1)
- OPEX (1)
- ORAPKI (1)
- Odbcs (1)
- Odbs (1)
- On-Premises (1)
- Ora-01852 (1)
- Ora-7445 (1)
- Oracle Cursor (1)
- Oracle Database Appliance (1)
- Oracle Database Se2 (1)
- Oracle Database Standard Edition 2 (1)
- Oracle Database Upgrade (1)
- Oracle Database@Google Cloud (1)
- Oracle Exadata Smart Scan (1)
- Oracle Licensing (1)
- Oracle Linux Virtualization Manager (1)
- Oracle Oda (1)
- Oracle Openworld (1)
- Oracle Parallelism (1)
- Oracle RMAN (1)
- Oracle Rdbms (1)
- Oracle Real Application Clusters (1)
- Oracle Reports (1)
- Oracle Security (1)
- Oracle Wallet (1)
- PDB (1)
- Perfomrance (1)
- Performance Schema (1)
- Policy (1)
- Prompt Engineering (1)
- Public Cloud (1)
- Pythian News (1)
- Rdb (1)
- Replication Compatibility (1)
- Replication Error (1)
- Retail (1)
- Scaling Ir (1)
- Securing Sql Server (1)
- Security Compliance (1)
- Serverless Computing (1)
- Sso (1)
- Tenserflow (1)
- Teradata (1)
- Vertex AI (1)
- Vertica (1)
- Videos (1)
- Workspace Security (1)
- Xbstream (1)
- July 2025 (3)
- June 2025 (1)
- May 2025 (3)
- March 2025 (2)
- February 2025 (1)
- January 2025 (2)
- December 2024 (1)
- October 2024 (2)
- September 2024 (7)
- August 2024 (4)
- July 2024 (2)
- June 2024 (6)
- May 2024 (3)
- April 2024 (2)
- February 2024 (1)
- January 2024 (11)
- December 2023 (10)
- November 2023 (11)
- October 2023 (10)
- September 2023 (8)
- August 2023 (6)
- July 2023 (2)
- June 2023 (13)
- May 2023 (4)
- April 2023 (6)
- March 2023 (10)
- February 2023 (6)
- January 2023 (5)
- December 2022 (10)
- November 2022 (10)
- October 2022 (10)
- September 2022 (13)
- August 2022 (16)
- July 2022 (12)
- June 2022 (13)
- May 2022 (11)
- April 2022 (4)
- March 2022 (5)
- February 2022 (4)
- January 2022 (14)
- December 2021 (16)
- November 2021 (11)
- October 2021 (6)
- September 2021 (11)
- August 2021 (6)
- July 2021 (9)
- June 2021 (4)
- May 2021 (8)
- April 2021 (16)
- March 2021 (16)
- February 2021 (6)
- January 2021 (12)
- December 2020 (12)
- November 2020 (17)
- October 2020 (11)
- September 2020 (10)
- August 2020 (11)
- July 2020 (13)
- June 2020 (6)
- May 2020 (9)
- April 2020 (18)
- March 2020 (21)
- February 2020 (13)
- January 2020 (15)
- December 2019 (10)
- November 2019 (11)
- October 2019 (12)
- September 2019 (16)
- August 2019 (15)
- July 2019 (10)
- June 2019 (16)
- May 2019 (20)
- April 2019 (21)
- March 2019 (14)
- February 2019 (18)
- January 2019 (18)
- December 2018 (5)
- November 2018 (16)
- October 2018 (12)
- September 2018 (20)
- August 2018 (27)
- July 2018 (31)
- June 2018 (34)
- May 2018 (28)
- April 2018 (27)
- March 2018 (17)
- February 2018 (8)
- January 2018 (20)
- December 2017 (14)
- November 2017 (4)
- October 2017 (1)
- September 2017 (3)
- August 2017 (5)
- July 2017 (4)
- June 2017 (2)
- May 2017 (7)
- April 2017 (7)
- March 2017 (8)
- February 2017 (8)
- January 2017 (5)
- December 2016 (3)
- November 2016 (4)
- October 2016 (8)
- September 2016 (9)
- August 2016 (10)
- July 2016 (9)
- June 2016 (8)
- May 2016 (13)
- April 2016 (16)
- March 2016 (13)
- February 2016 (11)
- January 2016 (6)
- December 2015 (11)
- November 2015 (11)
- October 2015 (5)
- September 2015 (16)
- August 2015 (4)
- July 2015 (1)
- June 2015 (3)
- May 2015 (6)
- April 2015 (5)
- March 2015 (5)
- February 2015 (4)
- January 2015 (3)
- December 2014 (7)
- October 2014 (4)
- September 2014 (6)
- August 2014 (6)
- July 2014 (16)
- June 2014 (7)
- May 2014 (6)
- April 2014 (5)
- March 2014 (4)
- February 2014 (10)
- January 2014 (6)
- December 2013 (8)
- November 2013 (12)
- October 2013 (9)
- September 2013 (6)
- August 2013 (7)
- July 2013 (9)
- June 2013 (7)
- May 2013 (7)
- April 2013 (4)
- March 2013 (7)
- February 2013 (4)
- January 2013 (4)
- December 2012 (6)
- November 2012 (8)
- October 2012 (9)
- September 2012 (3)
- August 2012 (5)
- July 2012 (5)
- June 2012 (7)
- May 2012 (11)
- April 2012 (1)
- March 2012 (8)
- February 2012 (1)
- January 2012 (6)
- December 2011 (8)
- November 2011 (5)
- October 2011 (9)
- September 2011 (6)
- August 2011 (4)
- July 2011 (1)
- June 2011 (1)
- May 2011 (5)
- April 2011 (2)
- February 2011 (2)
- January 2011 (2)
- December 2010 (1)
- November 2010 (7)
- October 2010 (3)
- September 2010 (8)
- August 2010 (2)
- July 2010 (4)
- June 2010 (7)
- May 2010 (2)
- April 2010 (1)
- March 2010 (3)
- February 2010 (3)
- January 2010 (2)
- November 2009 (6)
- October 2009 (6)
- August 2009 (3)
- July 2009 (3)
- June 2009 (3)
- May 2009 (2)
- April 2009 (8)
- March 2009 (6)
- February 2009 (4)
- January 2009 (3)
- November 2008 (3)
- October 2008 (7)
- September 2008 (6)
- August 2008 (9)
- July 2008 (9)
- June 2008 (9)
- May 2008 (9)
- April 2008 (8)
- March 2008 (4)
- February 2008 (3)
- January 2008 (3)
- December 2007 (2)
- November 2007 (7)
- October 2007 (1)
- August 2007 (4)
- July 2007 (3)
- June 2007 (8)
- May 2007 (4)
- April 2007 (2)
- March 2007 (2)
- February 2007 (5)
- January 2007 (8)
- December 2006 (1)
- November 2006 (3)
- October 2006 (4)
- September 2006 (3)
- July 2006 (1)
- May 2006 (2)
- April 2006 (1)
- July 2005 (1)
No Comments Yet
Let us know what you think