PaddedCell

How spotless works

Spotless works on a very simple principle

You specify a series of steps (trimTrailingWhitespace(), licenseHeader('/* Licensed under Apache-2.0 */'), etc.)
Each step is a Function<String, String> - takes a String as input, returns a String as output

When you call

spotlessApply, it reads a file, applies each step sequentially, then writes the output back to disk.
spotlessCheck, it reads a file, applies each step sequentially, and makes sure that the output of the steps is equal to the input. If not, it tells you which files are badly formatted, and asks you to run spotlessApply to fix them.

A misbehaving step

Let's imagine that we wrote a step like this:

custom 'pingpong', { input ->
  if (input.equals('A')) {
    return 'B'
  } else {
    return 'A'
  }
}

If our input file is CCCCCC, then the first time we call spotlessApply we'll get A, the next time B, the next time A, back and forth. This misbehaving rule is self-inconsistent - it doesn't know what it wants the format to be. Because of this, spotlessCheck will always fail.

The rule we wrote above is obviously a bad idea. But complex code formatters can have corner-cases where they exhibit exactly this behavior of ping-ponging between two states. It's also possible to have a cycle of more than two states.

Formally, a correct formatter F must satisfy F(F(input)) == F(input) for all values of input. Any formatter which doesn't meet this rule is misbehaving.

How spotless fixes this automatically

This is easiest to show in an example:

Two-state cycle: 'CCCC' 'A' 'B' 'A' ...
- F(F('CCC')) should equal F('CCC'), but it didn't, so we iterate until we find a cycle.
- In this case, that cycle turns out to be 'B' 'A'
- To resolve the ambiguity about which element in the cycle is "right", Spotless uses the lowest element sorted by first by length then alphabetically.
- In this case, A is the canonical form which will be used by spotlessApply and spotlessCheck.
Four-state cycle: 'CCCC' 'A' 'B' 'C' 'D' 'A' 'B' 'C' 'D'
- As above, we detect a cycle, and it turns out to be 'B' 'C' 'D' 'A'
- We resolve this cycle with the lowest element, which is A
Convergence: 'ATT' 'AT' 'A' 'A'
- F(F('ATT')) did not equal F('ATT'), but there is no cycle.
- Eventually, the sequence converged on A.
- As a result, we will use A as the canonical format.
Divergence: '1' '12' '123' '1234' '12345' ...
- This format does not cycle or converge
- As a result, the canonical format is whatever the starting value was, which is 1 in this case.
- PaddedCell gives up looking for a cycle or convergence and calls a sequence divergent after 10 tries.

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Uh oh!